Losing her was the hardest thing I've ever been through. Of course, there have been other hurts. Losing my first love, homesickness, but all of those invariably healed over time.
It's different with her. I still feel the pain of her leaving, although it has numbed considerably and I rarely let it out. But on those long drives on the interstate, it often comes up to the surface and begs to be seen. Maybe it was because she was one of the first people to take me places, to show me the world beyond my hometown. Maybe it was because she took me to work with her and opened my eyes to new things.
I often wonder if she knew how much she meant to me back then. I hung on her every word and I wanted to be like her in every way. I wanted to write like her, I wanted to dress like her, I wanted a car like hers, I wanted a life like hers. I even wanted dogs like hers. Her favorites were my favorites. When she left, I didn't even know what my favorite color was because it had always been hers. I remember buying the same shoes she had and being afraid she would wish I hadn't. I looked out the window, sat on the porch, and waited for her almost every evening.
It was a Friday when she told my parents she was leaving. I was not there, but I remember myself back in that Sears' dressing room the next day when my mom told me she was leaving. I remember time slowing down. I remember the shock, the disbelief, the wondering, the listening to my mom attempt to explain that which couldn't being explained. I remember my world changing that day, that moment in time in which my world split in half. I remember the visceral need I felt to see her, to talk to her. I remember calling and leaving a message that I wanted to see her when she got home- not knowing then that she was out telling others she was leaving while I was waiting for her to come home.
I waited for her that night and then I saw her, but I don't remember anything she said. I just remember seeing the hurt. I remember seeing the sheets that showed he was sleeping downstairs while she was sleeping upstairs. I remember her saying we could get ice cream the next day, on Sunday, one last time before she left on Monday.
On Sunday morning, I remember my youth minister pulling me close and enveloping me completely when I fell into her arms and told her what was happening. I remember crying and feeling like my world was crumbling beneath me.
I remember sitting on a picnic table getting ice cream together that Sunday afternoon, just the three of us, one last time, but not feeling like we used to. I remember seeing a made-up mind ready to move on and a broken heart not even knowing how to move.
I remember looking out the window Monday morning, seeing her parents' car there to pack her up and take her away. I remember wondering how all that could happen in one day.
I remember sitting on my best friend's couch saying it was the worst one of my life when her mom asked how my weekend was. I remember thinking that was a first!
I remember the grace of a sweet card from a friend the week after she left. That friend was sorry for my pain, and that card stayed on my dresser for months. It was a gentle reminder each morning that someone saw and cared about my pain and that there was still some good in the world.
I remember checking on him in those first days and weeks and I mostly remember silence and emptiness and wondering if things would ever be okay.
I remember learning of the pictures he sent with her so she would remember the life she left behind.
I remember thinking lots of homework was a good thing because it gave me something to focus on other than her.
I remember letters eagerly written and sent with my love and adoration for her professed. I remember waiting and waiting for replies. I remember letting my dad hold me like a baby in the recliner one evening as I cried. I remember his smell and I remember feeling safe. I can't remember if it was because there was no reply or because it hadn't been what I'd hoped.
I still have those letters in a box under my bed. They have moved with me umpteen times. I think there are three of them, and I sometimes wonder what it would be like to read them again after all these years. Would I read them differently now, as an adult, with so much time gone by?
I remember calling once, in a desperate last attempt to see her after an unanswered request. I can't remember if I cried on the phone to her mother or not. I remember learning in a letter that she had been out of town and unable to visit as I had hoped.
I remember going to a family dinner with him at a nice restaurant, the first one without her, trying hard to be okay and have fun.
I remember my mom cooking for him and the three of us going on walks in the evenings.
I remember the encouragement of a sweet friend who urged me to talk to her and share my feelings when I would see her in the fall to try to get some closure. I remember seeing her that one time in the fall, hoping for answers, but not really getting any. I remember her telling me the reason she didn’t call or write often was to make it easier for me.
I remember standing in my freshman dorm room when she called to invite me to her wedding. I remember where the phone was and what the room looked like and what I felt standing there. I remember it feeling surreal that she was talking to me like everything was fine and that she hadn't stopped communicating with me two years earlier. I remember feeling it would be disloyal for me to go. Besides, it was miles away, states away, and I was in college.
I remember learning of a friend who had stopped her parents from separating and feeling like I should have done more. I remember thinking if I had stayed close to her the last years she was there that maybe she would have stayed. I remember thinking I should have pitched a fit and begged her not to leave. I remember thinking that in some small way it was my fault or that at the very least I could have prevented it.
I remember inviting her to my wedding and getting no response. I remember this being the last time I tried. I remember getting a card a month after my wedding from her with his name, too. I remember thinking it might have been better if I had gotten nothing.
I remember talking to two different counselors about her, about the possibility of contacting her. One said I should let her know in advance and asked me what my expectations were. Years later, the other one said she may not have known how important she was to me, and I may not have been as important to her as she was to me. She said that in the midst of all she was going through at the time, she probably wasn’t thinking much about me. She said if she hadn’t initiated contact, she had probably moved on. I think those were the hardest words to hear. How could she not have known? How could I not have mattered to her as much as she mattered to me?
Four months ago, when I wrote this post, it ended here in this sad place. It ended with me wanting to know if I ever even mattered to her. But the Lord in His graciousness wouldn't leave me there.
Now I can see that she was swept up in other things and other people. Now I can see that none of that minimizes the close relationship we had in previous years. Now I can see that she probably loved me in her own way, even if she didn't express it well. Now I can see that I am not responsible for her choices. Now I can see how it would have been hard for her to keep in touch with me. Now I can see that as a child, I could not understand everything that was happening. Now I can see that people aren't meant to be saviors. Now I can see that it was never God's desire for me to be hurt by her. (A sermon here by Jen Hatmaker on 9/6/15 helped with this.)
Many years have passed, and I have grown in a lot of ways- in relationship ways and in spiritual ways. I used to need validation and approval from others to feel okay. It has taken such a long time, but I do not need those things anymore. I can treasure my friends and family and the good times we have without needing them to make me okay. I can accept them wholly- with all of their strengths and shortcomings. I can appreciate them more readily and forgive them more freely. My happiness is not dependent on their performance.
I have finally, finally found my worth in Jesus. I have had a relationship with Him since I was 13 years old, but I tried to earn His approval the next 18 years of my life. It has just been in the last few months that I have taken hold of the truth that Jesus is my righteousness. I can not be good enough, do enough good things, or try hard enough to earn God's favor or approval. I actually already have it because I trusted in Jesus to forgive me and make me clean back on that hot July night when I walked down the aisle and sang, "I Have Decided to Follow Jesus." Jesus stands in my place and He is all that God sees when He looks at me. I am so, so thankful to God for revealing this truth to me through Scripture, song, Bible study, and discussion with other believers. I think my 32nd year is going to be my best year yet because I am finally, finally free.
Before the throne of God above
I have a strong and perfect plea
A great High Priest whose name is love
Who ever lives and pleads for me
My name is graven on His hands
My name is written on His heart
I know that while in heaven He stands
No tongue can bid me thence depart
No tongue can bid me thence depart
When Satan tempts me to despair
And tells me of the guilt within
Upward I look and see Him there
Who made an end of all my sin
Because the sinless Savior died
My sinful soul is counted free
For God the just is satisfied
To look on Him and pardon me
To look on Him and pardon me
Hallelujah, hallelujah
Praise the One, Risen Son of God
Behold Him there, the risen Lamb
My perfect, spotless Righteousness
The great unchangeable I AM
The King of glory and of grace
One in Himself, I cannot die
My soul is purchased by His blood
My life is hid with Christ on high
With Christ my Savior and my God
With Christ my Savior and my God
Hallelujah, hallelujah
Praise the One, Risen Son of God